
A calming influence: Managing conflict and difficult conversations in the university classroom

A calming influence: Managing conflict and difficult conversations in the university classroom
At CTLI, we've compiled resources for educators to review when preparing for potentially contentious classroom discussions Domestic and global conflicts and controversies often impact our students in diverse and uniquely personal ways. Some MSU educators mentioned increased tension and potential for disruptions in your classroom. Students are coming to learn with a diverse array of perspectives, experiences, and identities that shape how they experience the world. Navigating classroom discussions on charged societal issues or current events can be extremely challenging.
The resources curated here offer guidance on fostering civil discourse and managing disruptive behavior in the classroom. We hope these resources equip you with strategies and best practices for maintaining a respectful learning environment where all students feel safe and heard. This collection includes guidelines on setting expectations for dialogue, maintaining calm, tips for redirecting off-topic or uncivil comments, sample facilitation methods for controversial discussions, and ways to de-escalate a hot-moment.
As educators, we all share the responsibility of creating classrooms where learning can thrive. In times of tension, our first priority should be to seek to understand. The role of the teacher in conflict situations is to be the agent of calm, to seek to diffuse tension, and to foster an environment where learning can happen whenever possible. With compassion and care, we can model civil engagement across differences, while also drawing reasonable boundaries around conduct. Our hope is that these resources will help equip you to handle tense situations with wisdom, patience and cultural sensitivity. (please note this collection is in progress)
The resources curated here offer guidance on fostering civil discourse and managing disruptive behavior in the classroom. We hope these resources equip you with strategies and best practices for maintaining a respectful learning environment where all students feel safe and heard. This collection includes guidelines on setting expectations for dialogue, maintaining calm, tips for redirecting off-topic or uncivil comments, sample facilitation methods for controversial discussions, and ways to de-escalate a hot-moment.
As educators, we all share the responsibility of creating classrooms where learning can thrive. In times of tension, our first priority should be to seek to understand. The role of the teacher in conflict situations is to be the agent of calm, to seek to diffuse tension, and to foster an environment where learning can happen whenever possible. With compassion and care, we can model civil engagement across differences, while also drawing reasonable boundaries around conduct. Our hope is that these resources will help equip you to handle tense situations with wisdom, patience and cultural sensitivity. (please note this collection is in progress)

Authored by
Center for Teaching and Learning Innovation
{"id"=>3717, "level_no"=>1, "level_title"=>"Proactive Inclusive Environments", "notes"=>"Here are materials, resources, and activities that can help educators establish inclusive, welcoming learning environments.", "challenge_id"=>399, "created_at"=>Tue, 17 Oct 2023 17:34:24.618003000 UTC +00:00, "updated_at"=>Tue, 17 Oct 2023 17:34:24.618003000 UTC +00:00}
Here is a great bibliography of articles related to teaching about oppression in your classes. It was compiled by the History Department of Brown University
https://www.brown.edu/sheridan/sites/sheridan/files/docs/engaging-oppression-in-classrooms-bibliography.pdf
This is an interesting learning opportunity. This three module short course will help you:
- Identify the basic tenets of anti-racism and anti-racist teaching
- Understand your positionality, social identities and biases, as well as their impact on your teaching
- Create safe and inclusive classroom environments for the discussion of sensitive topics
- Implement anti-racist practices and strategies within your teaching and learning environment
https://taylorinstitute.ucalgary.ca/resources/module/anti-racism-edi-positionality
link
Description
Here are materials and resources that can help educators prepare for and address challenging conversations and conflict in learning environments.
Challenging Classroom Conversations
Challenging Classroom Conversations
Challenging Classroom Conversations
Responding to conflict or a heated moment? Begin response statements with some combination of your levels of understanding and agreement:
I understand what you’re saying but I disagree with…
I don’t understand this element of your statement…
I agree with you on some of the things you’ve said, but in this way I disagree…
Help me to understand…
Check out the attached file for additional conflict resolution sentence starters "for Healthy Conflict" from Elena Aguilar's (2016) "The Art of Coaching Teams: Building Resilient Communities that Transform Schools" (published by Jossey-Bass).
Disruptive Students - This was an assumed issue just for K-12 settings. However, we have the current events and issues impact students at all levels in different ways. This is an older resource that helps to identify specific disruptive behavior types and offers some strategies for dealing with them.
attached here and accessible at:
https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1590876479/northwestmsedu/mrlaokp6aqomejlcpd2f/copingwith7disruptivepersonalitytypes.pdf link
Walden University has shared...
"There are many different scenarios for classroom conflicts, and not all can be resolved in the same manner; however, there are five key conflict resolution strategies that should be understood. Often a topic among teachers in online master’s degree programs, these strategies, when implemented appropriately, can help create a classroom that is more conducive to learning. They also help teach students valuable lessons for conflict resolution that can last a lifetime."
To learn more about the five conflict resolution strategies (Problem-solving negotiations, Smoothing, Forcing or win-lose negotiations, Compromising, Withdrawing) visit: https://www.waldenu.edu/online-masters-programs/master-of-arts-in-teaching/resource/five-strategies-for-managing-conflict-in-the-classroom link
The University of Waterloo's Center for Faculty Excellence has shared some interesting approaches for engaging students who are disruptive to your classroom learning environments:
1. Ask the students if they have a question. Sometimes talking during class is legitimate; students have missed a key definition or number and need clarification from someone sitting nearby.
2. Move closer to the disruptive students. Your proximity may signal to them that they are interrupting the class.
3. Make a general statement to the class about the disruption. If you do not feel comfortable singling people out, you can indicate to the class in general that the disruption level is too high and remind them of the ground rules you set on day one.
4. Use an active learning activity. Try a think-pair-share where you have students turn to the person next to them to discuss a problem or question. This will break up the flow of the class and help to re-capture students’ attention. It will also give you an opportunity to approach the disruptive students and discuss your concern with them.
5. Ask those who consistently disrupt the class to see you after class. This will give you an opportunity to air your concerns outside of class and indicate your displeasure with the students’ behavior without embarrassing them in front of the class.
(Large Classes: Limiting the Chaos. Centre for Teaching Excellence, University of Waterloo)
https://uwaterloo.ca/centre-for-teaching-excellence/catalogs/tip-sheets/large-classes-limiting-chaos link
Description
Where can MSU educators go to access additional support, resources, or consultation?
OK
OK
Cancel