Browse

Introduction:
As educators we seek to enhance student engagement and learning outcomes, exploring innovative grading strategies can offer fresh perspectives and effective solutions. Here’s a concise overview of five innovative grading practices:

1. Transparent Grading:


What is it? Transparent grading involves clearly defining and communicating grading criteria, processes, and feedback to students.


Key Elements: Detailed rubrics, open communication, student involvement.


Benefits: Enhanced understanding, improved performance, increased trust.


2. Self-Grading:


What is it? Self-grading allows students to assess their own work, promoting reflection and autonomy.


Key Elements: Self-assessment, reflection, feedback loops.


Benefits: Empowers students, promotes deeper learning, supports self-regulation.


3. Peer Grading (Peer Review):


What is it? Peer grading involves students assessing each other’s work, enhancing collaboration and responsibility.


Key Elements: Peer evaluation, feedback exchange, critical thinking.


Benefits: Deepens understanding, builds skills, fosters collaboration.


4. Gameful or Gamified Grading:


What is it? Gameful grading integrates game design elements, such as points, badges, and leaderboards, into the grading process.


Key Elements: Gamification, student choice, immediate feedback.


Benefits: Increases engagement, enhances mastery, supports skill development.


5. Ungrading:


What is it?: Ungrading minimizes or eliminates traditional grades in favor of detailed feedback and alternative assessments.


Key Elements: Detailed feedback, self-assessment, focus on growth.


Benefits: Promotes deep learning, reduces stress, supports equity.


Explore these strategies to boost student engagement and learning outcomes!

Learning Objectives

Define a transparent Purpose
Describe the importance of the “purpose” section and its relation to motivation and engagement.
Identify whether the transparency of a purpose statement is weak or strong

Introduction
This is part 2 of a 5 part series of articles on Transparent Assignment Design (Part 1: TAD). The first component of the Transparent Assignment Design (TAD) framework has to do with the Purpose. The purpose explains “the why” to the learner. 
The Significance of Transparency in Purpose
"Why am I learning this?" "What is the point of this?" "How is this going to help me in the long run?" "Is this just busy work?" "How am I going to use this in the future?"
These are common questions learners ask themselves, their peers, and even instructors when they don't understand why they are being asked to complete a course assignment or activity. The purpose of an assignment may be crystal clear to an instructor, but students who are new to the content and skills need a direct connection to its relevance clearly stated in order to see its importance. As a former Instructional Designer and current Engagement and Assessment Consultant, I have reviewed hundreds of assignments and the purpose of an assignment is often the key element that is missing. But why is it so important? 
As a former Psychology instructor and attention researcher, I can attest that people are more engaged in activities (stay on task longer, less distractible, and demonstrate more grit when working through difficult exercises) when they understand the relevance of the activity to their personal goals. Engagement and motivation are enhanced when learners grasp what will be gained by completing the assignment.
Psychology research classifies motivation into two main types: "Extrinsic Motivation" and "Intrinsic Motivation."

Extrinsic Motivation involves tangible rewards for engaging with the activity, such as points, prizes, money, and grades. While it is fast-acting, it tends to burn out quickly.
Intrinsic Motivation relates to how people personally feel about the activity, such as social engagement, enjoyment, meaningfulness, and relevance to long-term goals. It is harder to generate artificially but has a longer, more sustained effect when it is achieved.

Though many students will be initially extrinsically motivated to complete an assignment (for its grade), learners are more likely to demonstrate more effort and submit a higher caliber deliverable when the assignment can tap into their intrinsic motivation. A well-written Purpose statement can assist in fostering intrinsic motivation.
When we explain the purpose of an assignment to learners, it is essential to address both the short-term benefits (e.g., practicing applying specific knowledge and skills) and the long-term benefits (e.g., preparing for future professions). By doing so, we help students see the immediate value and future relevance of their efforts, fostering both extrinsic and intrinsic motivation.

Watch:


Examples:
Weak Purpose Statement:
Assignment: Analyze a data set and write a report on your findings.
Purpose Statement: This assignment will help you understand data analysis.
Explanation: This purpose statement is too vague and does not explain why understanding data analysis is important or how it will benefit the students in the short or long term. It lacks specificity and fails to connect the assignment to the students' broader goals or interests.
Strong Purpose Statement:
Assignment: Analyze a data set and write a report on your findings.
Purpose Statement: This assignment aims to enhance your ability to analyze real-world data using commonly used statistical methods. By completing this task, you will develop critical skills in data interpretation, statistical software proficiency, and report writing. These skills are essential for advanced coursework in statistics and highly valued in various professional fields, including business analytics, public health, and social sciences.
Explanation: This purpose statement clearly articulates the benefits of the assignment, both in the short term (developing data interpretation and statistical software skills) and in the long term (preparing for advanced coursework and professional fields). It connects the task to the students' academic and professional goals, making the relevance of the assignment explicit.

Resources: 
Note: This is article 2 of a 5-part series on Transparent Assignments.

 Quick Guide to Transparent Assignments (CTLI:MSU)

Learning Objectives

Define transparent Task instructions
Describe the importance of clearly written task instructions in an assignment
List 10 tips for writing clearly stated task assignment instructions.
Identify whether the transparency in a set of task instructions is weak or strong 

Introduction
This is part 3 of a 5 part series of articles on Transparent Assignment Design (Part 1, Part 2)The second critical element of a transparent assignment is the Task. The task is what students should do and deals with the actions the students have to take to complete the assignment. 
The Significance of Transparency in Task
Have you ever had to follow a cooking recipe or build a piece of furniture with poor instructions? Perhaps the instructions were word-heavy or confusing, the steps were out of order, a step was missing, or the diagrams were incorrect, confusing, or absent. When writing instructions for an assignment, especially multi-step, scaffolded types of assignments, we need to think like Instructional Designers. A guiding question that should be at the forefront of an Instructional Designer’s mind is: How could a non-expert complete this activity with the fewest errors? Our goal as educators is to set students up for success, not to create obstacles with unclear instructions. Instructions should be concise, straightforward, include all the required tools/resources, and be seamless to follow.
The "Task" section explains to students the steps they need to take to complete the assignment. It often includes any additional resources that students will need, such as data sets, articles to cite, websites to visit, etc.

Watch:

10 Tips for Writing an Effective “Task” Section:
1. Keep it Simple:

Avoid text-heavy instructions. Over-explaining can lead to distraction and confusion.

2. Use Positive and Direct Instructions:

Cognitive psychologists have found that it is easier for our brains to process what ‘to do’ than what ‘not to do’. If you must add avoidance statements, start with what students should do first.
Focus on direct instructions for what students should do, and limit how often you focus on what students should not do.
Example: Instead of saying, "Don’t forget to use APA style," say, "Use APA style for citations."

3. Consistent Formatting:

Use sparing bolding, underlining, italicizing, highlighting, all caps and font color.
Overuse of these features can create accessibility problems for screen readers and dilute the importance of truly key information.

4. Utilize Visual Aids:

Incorporate screenshots, mini-videos, gifs, and diagrams. As the saying goes, pictures can speak a thousand words and sometimes it's just easier to see someone carry out the task first.

5. Use Lists:

Numbered or bulleted lists help cut back on words and make instructions clearer. Avoid excessive levels of granularity in your lists (e.g., 1.2.5.14), which can be confusing.

6. Leverage Collaborative Tools:

Consider using Google Docs or other collaborative, cloud-based processors instead of the upload/download method of sharing assignment documents. 
The perks of using cloud-based processors include avoiding multiple versions of the same document, allowing for seamless updates, embedding of images, videos, and hyperlinks, allowing for students to “comment” on the document.

7. Hyperlink to Resources:

This increases usability and reduces time spent searching for materials buried in the course by centralizing all necessary resources to complete the assignment in one spot.

8. Consistent Labeling of Key Terms:

Use consistent terminology. Avoid using different labels for the same concept, as this can be confusing, especially for non-experts and second-language speakers.

9. Provide Troubleshooting Tips:

Include a separate document with common issues and their solutions, linked from the main instructions. Invite students to help curate this FAQ.

10. Seek Feedback:

Have someone unfamiliar with the assignment go through the instructions or use a generative AI tool to identify areas for improvement in usability and understanding.


Examples of Tasks Instructions
Weak Task Instructions:
Assignment: Write a Literary Analysis Essay on a Novel of Your Choice.
Task Section: Read the novel and write an essay about it.
Explanation: This task section is too vague and lacks specificity. It doesn’t provide clear steps, structure, or resources, leaving students uncertain about what is expected.

Strong Task Instructions:
Assignment: Write a Literary Analysis Essay on a Novel of Your Choice.
Task:

Choose a Novel:


Select a novel from the provided list in the course’s Week 2 folder. Ensure your choice is approved by [date].

2. Read the Novel:

Read the entire novel. Take notes on key themes, characters, and plot points as you read.

3. Develop a Thesis Statement:

Craft a clear, arguable thesis statement that reflects your analysis of the novel. Your thesis should focus on a specific theme, character, or literary device.

4. Gather Evidence:

Collect textual evidence (quotes, passages) from the novel to support your thesis. Make sure to note the page numbers for proper citation.

5. Outline Your Essay:

Create an outline that includes an introduction, body paragraphs, and a conclusion. Each body paragraph should focus on a single point that supports your thesis.

6. Write the First Draft:

Write the first draft of your essay, following the outline. Ensure your essay is 1500-2000 words in length and includes an introduction with a thesis statement, body paragraphs with evidence, and a conclusion.

7. Use MLA Formatting:

Format your essay according to MLA guidelines. Include in-text citations and a Works Cited page for the novel and any other sources you reference.

8. Peer Review:

Submit your draft to the peer review forum by [date]. Review at least two of your classmates' essays and provide constructive feedback.

9. Revise and Edit:

Based on peer feedback and your own review, revise and edit your essay. Focus on clarity, coherence, and correct grammar.

10. Submit the Final Essay:

Submit your final essay via the course’s online portal by [date]. Ensure you attach your draft with peer review comments.

Resources:

Refer to the “Literary Analysis Guide” available in the Resources folder for detailed instructions on developing a thesis and gathering evidence.
Use the “MLA Formatting Guide” linked [here] for help with citations and formatting.

Submission Checklist:

Thesis statement
Evidence from the text with citations
Outline
Draft with peer comments
Final essay in MLA format

Explanation: 
This task section is detailed and structured, providing clear, step-by-step instructions and necessary resources. It specifies what students need to do at each stage, the tools they should use, and deadlines, ensuring that students understand how to proceed and complete the assignment effectively.

Resources: 
Note: This is article 3 of a 5-part series on Transparent Assignments.

Quick Guide to Transparent Assignments (CTLI:MSU)

Quiz Question Converter Tools

Use any of these tools to import questions into a D2L quiz/exam in bulk from your Word document. It is recommended to save a copy of your exam and then make formatting edits for pasting into the tool. If you do all of your edits in the textbox for the tool, you could lose your work. In some cases, it works to create a text file (use Notepad on a PC) and paste questions as text from your Word doc. Then you can add asterisks in front of the correct answer, which is needed in most of the tools.


Recommended Converter Tool:


Algonquin College Brightspace Test Question Generator opens in new window

All question numbers and enumerations are removed, which allows for moving questions around and shuffling questions in the quiz. Edit each question after importing to D2L and use “Options" to add enumeration back in, if needed. Randomization of answer choices is possible by editing each question individually and selecting the option. Includes fill-in-the-blank, which comes through as a short answer (SA) type. This tool is recommended because it is less sensitive to spaces and gives a clear indication when the formatting of a question has an issue. Images can be added into the quiz later (per question using Insert Image). 

Other question converter tools(ordered in level of complexity):



Easy D2L CSV Multiple Choice Quiz Generator opens in new windowAll question numbers and enumerations are retained in the question and choices; this makes randomizing, moving question order, and shuffling difficult. Only uses MC, Multiple Choice, type. Images will need to be added to the quiz later.
D2L Quiz Question Converter Module opens in new window This tool has been added within this site, so you do not have to go to the Brightspace Community to use it. The link above will take you to the sub-module that contains the converter tool. This tool has more features, such as adding feedback and hints. It removes question numbers and allows you to keep enumerations (abcd) or remove them.The formatting for questions in this tool is sensitive to spacing. For example, you cannot have a space after the answer True. The Algonquin tool is not as sensitive to spacing issues.Note: See the D2L Quiz Question Converter blog opens in new window for more information on this tool.
Respondus 4.0 Exam Authoring opens in new windowThis PC-only software download is the most feature rich and has a higher learning curve. Use this option if your questions include images. Instructions are included in the MSU Respondus Community self-enrollment opens in new window course. You can upload your Word document without having to use an online text editor and images can be brought into all questions where they exist.Importing a Quiz Into D2L Using Respondus opens in new window - this article from IUP explains the process, however, use the information in the link above to access the Respondus software at MSU.  



More on Assessment strategies and test security issues in this site:



Alternative End-Of-Year Assessment Strategies opens in new window
Online Test Security (settings, time limits, and submission views)



Contact the MSU Service Desk for support.

Are you ready to level up your teaching game and promote equity in your classroom? Introducing Transparent Assignment Design (or TAD for short)! This powerful, yet easy to implement, framework not only makes your assignments crystal clear but also ensures inclusivity and fairness. By providing clear expectations and support, TAD helps level the playing field and gives every student a chance to shine. I have personally found that redesigning assignments using the TAD framework has led to (Mills, M.L. (formerly Rosen, M.L.) et al., 2022):

improved quality of student submissions
reduced requests for regrades
reduced late submissions
reduced student frustration

An assignment that utilizes the TAD framework includes three important sections:

Purpose - an explanation on how the knowledge and skills used in this activity are relevant to a student and their future.
Task - a detailed explanation of the steps a student needs to take to complete the assignment.
Criteria - an explanation for how student's submission of the assignment will be evaluated.

In the next set of articles in this playlist, we will expand on each of these sections by describing what a good Purpose, Task, and Criteria looks like. At the end of the playlist we will provide with a template to get you started.Resources:

TILT Higher Ed Examples and Resources
Transparent Assignment Design | Center for Advancing Teaching and Learning Through Research (northeastern.edu)
Quick Guide to Transparent Assignment Design (wsu.edu)

MSU Scoring & Assessment Services offers an online assessment solution through DigitalDesk WebAssess, as well as StudentPortal, the student gateway to assessment scores and results. This online solution provides in-class, remote, proctored, and testing center assessment options, standard and custom reports, management of supplemental materials and test aids, and more.
In addition to secure online testing through DigitalDesk WebAssess, MSU Scoring & Assessment Services provides bubble sheet scanning for objective tests, general data collection, the Student Instructional Rating System (SIRS), and other MSU instructional evaluations/surveys.  Both online and bubble sheet testing includes a full complement of reports: item analysis, test statistics, student feedback, and grade keeping (see examples of DigitalDesk Reports).
Students can take exams on WebAssess or in the classroom on bubble sheets with combined reporting.  Make-up tests can be added to the same exam at any time, either from WebAssess or bubble sheets. The MSU Scoring & Assessment Services image scanners create an image of the bubble sheet so essay questions and other types of questions can be graded online by the instructor.  These types of questions can also be pre-graded by the instructor entering scores into the score boxes included on the bubble sheets.   
MSU funds MSU Scoring & Assessment Services for all MSU courses. There is no cost for departments or students. For non-instructional assessments, see Non-Instructional Pricing.
The MSU Scoring & Assessment Services Office also provides:

Crowdmark scanning and support
D2L quiz/exam and grade book support
Gradescope scanning and support
LON-CAPA scanning
Respondus/LockDown Browser support
Qualtrics technical support
Custom form design
Custom scanning programs

CONTACT
MSU Scoring & Assessment ServicesComputer Center450 Auditorium Road, Room 114East Lansing, MI 48824(517) 355-1819scoring@msu.edu

The following is taken from a help page in d2l. Please follow this link to learn more. There are many issues, such as accessibility,  to consider when considering exam proctoring.






Determining Whether to Use Respondus
If you determine that remote proctoring is required to assess student learning in your course, the Respondus Lockdown Browser and Respondus Monitor tools provide a method for securing online exams. This document provides an overview of the features of Respondus LockDown Browser and Respondus Monitor, along with a step-by-step guide for how to activate these systems for your assessments in D2L. It also includes a quick start guide for students on taking a test with Respondus LockDown Browser and/or Monitor enabled.
What You Should Consider Before Using Respondus LockDown Browser and Monitor
Before choosing to use Respondus tools, you will want to:

UPDATED 09/23/2020: Once enabled, students must use Respondus Lockdown browser and Monitor(Optional) unless an instructor specifically excludes a student from use of the service via Special Access under the Restrictions tab when editing quiz settings.
Assess whether all of your students have access to a functioning webcam: Instructors who want to use the LockDown Browser in conjunction with Respondus Monitor should check with their students to ensure that each student has a functioning webcam. If students do not have a webcam, Respondus Monitor settings will not work, and students will be unable to open or take any assessment with Monitor settings enabled
Consider creating a practice assessment for students to test out the Respondus systems: Establishing a practice quiz with LockDown Browser and/or Monitor settings enabled allows students the opportunity to download the software in advance, and gives them a sense of what to expect on the day of their actual exam. It also allows you and your students to identify any potential challenges that may emerge with the system. Consider creating a one or two question quiz with a fun prompt to give students a chance to see how the software functions.
Consider accessibility and assistive technology needs for your students: Respondus LockDown Browser and Monitor both have limitations when it comes to accessibility and their ability to be accessed with assistive technology. Please consider the accessibility needs of your students before deciding to move forward with LockDown Browser or Monitor. Further information on these limitations is outlined in the "Accessibility Considerations" section below.

Accessibility Considerations
Respondus Lockdown Browser has limitations when it comes to accessibility and being accessed with assistive technology:

Screen Reader Technology: The Mac version will work with VoiceOver (standard screen reader that comes with Mac OS). For Windows, students must have the most current version of LockDown Browser. If it is the most current version, then NVDA, JAWS, Narrator, ReadSpeaker webReader, and Windows-Eyes screen readers should work. NVDA is proven to provide the best screen reader experience and can be downloaded for free at: https://www.nvaccess.org/
The security level of LockDown Browser is lowered when screen readers are being used.
Screen Magnification: Zoom Text will work with LockDown browser to enlarge and increase the text size, but LockDown browser is NOT compatible with the reader functions in Zoom Text.
Text to Speech: Students who need to utilize reading technology, text to speech, such as Kurzweil 3000 will NOT be able to use LockDown Browser. LockDown Browser is NOT compatible with any text to speech tools.
Respondus Monitor raises concerns for students with visual or mobility disabilities, as they may not be able to accurately show an ID to the webcam in order to pass certain checkpoints.